Casey Key - Exclusive Homes on the Gulf

Casey Key - Exclusive Homes on the Gulf


Align with the Stars on Casey Key

A Narrow Barrier Island with Lush Trees and Mansions on Sandy Beaches

It is not unusual to spy a Bentley, Rolls-Royce or limousine traversing the streets of Casey Key, an island that is secure and private with a connection to the mainland off Nokomis, Florida.

Actress Rosie O’Donnell is the latest celebrity to purchase a home in Casey Key, following the lead of such notables as thrill author Stephen King.

A drive along Casey Key Dr will reveal some of the most elegant homes on the west coastCasey Key is the southernmost key of the west coast Florida barrier island chain that stretches northward to Siesta Key, Lido Key, Longboat Key and Anna Maria Island. The word "Key" is derived from the Spanish word for small island “Cayo”.

For the most part Casey Key is very narrow and supports one main road on its eight-mile trek north and south. Casey Key Road connects to the mainland across Blackburn Bay on Blackburn Point Road and at its southern tip on Albee Road, with a quick connection to I-75 from either entry. Casey Key road is lined with palm, pine and oak trees with old mansion charm and modern, well-styled luxury real estate properties.

The two Casey Key bridges are your links to a world of stylish restaurants. The North Jetty Park on the southern tip is a popular hangout for fishing, relaxing or sunbathing in the white sands that meet the turquoise color waters of the Gulf of Mexico. This beach park is frequented by surfers for its curls and is maintained by Sarasota County.

With easy access to Sarasota residents can explore a rich culture that this city has to offer. Sarasota was ranked as the top art destination in the nation for small cities by readers of American Style Magazine in 2012. Bradenton to the north was rated second by readers of the magazine. This distinguishes these two adjoining cities as one of the top cultural areas in United States.

If golf is your interest, a short drive to Nokomis and Venice uncovers a rich area for fine green grass courses. Tennis is a popular recreational sport on the island. If you own a sail boat or yacht, consider membership in the Casey Key Marina & Yacht Club. With all the water that surrounds you there are plenty of opportunities for beach or deep sea fishing.

Expect a healthy living lifestyle with daytime temperatures above 70 degrees in the winter and moderate temperatures in the summer as breezes from the gulf account for a pleasant climate.

Sign up now for home listings in Casey Key sent to you daily by email. This is a FREE service to help area home buyers find their dream home. Your first email will list all homes currently for sale that meet your search criteria.

Invest in the secure, private and relaxing island of Casey Key.

Search for Casey Key active homes for sale

Find your perfect Casey Key luxury home for sale

North Jetty Park on Casey Key
The North Jetty Park on Casey Key, a popular site for fishing and kayaking.

Why Choose
Roger Pettingell?


  • Over 33 years as a top producing REALTOR® on Longboat Key and in Sarasota.


  • Number 1 single Coldwell Banker agent in all of Florida for 2008, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017
  • Number 1 Realtor on Longboat Key and Bird Key for 2008, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2018
  • Number 1 Realtor for all Sarasota in 2008, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2018
  • Coldwell Banker Society of Excellence award in 2013, 2014 and 2016
  • Ranked among the top 250 agents in the country for 2014, 2016 and 2017 by REAL Trends as reported in the Wall Street Journal.

Personal Consult Today

Sign up here and receive a personal consultation with Roger today to buy your next home or sell your existing property.

Free Home Value Analysis (Selling)

Receive your FREE Home Value Analysis for your real estate property on Longboat Key or surrounding area.

FREE Home Value Analysis

About Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell of Coldwell Banker Residential Real Estate is your Longboat Key, Florida Luxury Real Estate Specialist. Roger provides his real estate expertise to sellers, investors, developers, and buyers in the Sarasota area including Anna Maria, Bird Key, Bradenton Beach, Casey Key, Cortez, Grand Bay, Holmes Beach, Longboat Key, Marina Bay, Osprey and Siesta Key. Search for homes, luxury homes, condominiums, investment property, development property, and vacant land and lots on the Longboat Key, Florida and the surrounding area.